C-

Carthage, NY

Source:

Affordability Score: 53/100

Population: 10,901 · 1 ZIP codes

The affordability dashboard for Carthage, NY aggregates Census ACS 5-Year Estimates across 1 ZIP code covering 10,901 residents, then layers in county-level federal data to produce an overall grade of C- (53/100). The headline inputs are median household income of $63,120, median home value of $178,700, median rent of $959 per month, and 18.8% of adults holding a bachelor's degree or higher. These four metrics alone explain most of the variance between city dashboards.

Cross-agency feeds widen the picture beyond Census demographics. HUD publishes a Fair Market Rent for a 2-bedroom in this county at $1,405 per month (studio $969, 1BR $1,071, 3BR $1,907, 4BR $2,340). Department of Labor data lists infant center-based childcare at $12,844 per year, consuming 20% of the local median household income.

Reading the overall grade requires reading all seven dimensions together. The score weights Income 20%, Safety 20%, Housing 15%, Rent 15%, Education 10%, Commute 10%, and Childcare 10%, with each sub-score benchmarked against national percentiles rather than state averages — so the grade is genuinely comparable across any city in the country. Pressure points are education, childcare. Unemployment currently reads 7.7% and poverty 18.6% — numbers worth keeping alongside the headline grade.

Score Breakdown

Income C-
$63,120
Median household income
Education F
18.8%
Bachelor's degree or higher
Housing B
2.8x
Home value $178,700 vs income
Commute C+
23 min
Average commute time
Rent C+
$1,405/mo
2BR fair market rent (27% of income)
Safety N/A
N/A
Violent crime rate (county)
Childcare F
$12,844/yr
Center-based infant care (20% of income)

Income & Employment

Median Income
$63,120
▲ 2% vs national
Per Capita Income
$33,678
Unemployment Rate
7.7%
Poverty Rate
18.6%

Housing

Median Home Value
$178,700
▼ 35% vs national
Median Rent
$959/mo
Owner Occupied
56.3%
2BR Fair Market Rent
$1,405/mo
▲ 17% vs national

Fair Market Rents by Bedroom

Studio
$969
1BR
$1,071
2BR
$1,405
3BR
$1,907
4BR
$2,340

Safety

Violent Crime Rate
Data Source
FBI UCR (county-level)

Education & Family

Bachelor's Degree+
18.8%
▼ 11 ppt vs national
High School+
59.3%
Median Age
37.6
Avg. Commute
23 min
▼ 3 min vs national

Childcare Costs

Infant (Center)
$12,844/yr
20% of income
Toddler (Center)
$11,960/yr
Preschool (Center)
$10,400/yr
School-Age (Center)
$10,088/yr

What This Means

Carthage, NY receives an overall affordability grade of C- (53/100), aggregated from 1 ZIP codes with a total population of 10,901. Challenges include education and childcare. Data was unavailable for safety — these dimensions were excluded from the overall score.

Nearby City Dashboards

Explore Carthage ZIP Codes
View all 1 ZIP codes with demographics and individual scorecards
View ZIPs →

What are common questions about this dashboard?

Is Carthage, NY affordable?
Carthage, NY receives an overall affordability grade of C- (53/100) based on Census, HUD, FBI, and DOL data. Median household income is $63,120. Median home value is $178,700.
What is the cost of living in Carthage?
Key cost metrics: Median rent $959/mo. 2BR fair market rent $1,405/mo. Infant childcare $12,844/yr. Median home value $178,700.
How is the affordability score calculated?
The score evaluates 7 dimensions weighted by importance: Income (20%), Safety (20%), Housing (15%), Rent (15%), Education (10%), Commute (10%), and Childcare (10%). Each metric is compared against national percentile benchmarks from Census, HUD, FBI, and DOL data.

Data as of 2024. Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACS 5-Year Estimates. Source: HUD Fair Market Rents. Source: FBI Uniform Crime Report. Source: DOL National Database of Childcare Prices. Verify with HUD →