Middle Island, NY

Middle Island, NY is covered by 1 USPS ZIP code serving a combined population of 13,553 according to Census ACS 5-Year Estimates. U.S. cities rarely map cleanly to a single ZIP — Middle Island splits its residents across 1 delivery areas, each with its own demographic and housing profile. The table below lists every ZIP by population, so you can see which neighborhoods carry the weight of the city total and which are smaller pockets of the same municipal boundary.

Aggregated across every ZIP in Middle Island, the median household income averages $86,206 and per-capita income averages $44,471. Poverty rate runs at 11.7% and unemployment at 6.5%. On housing, the average median home value is $397,800 with median rent of $2,054 per month, and 66.6% of occupied units are owner-occupied. These are arithmetic averages across the 1 ZIP — not population-weighted — so small ZIPs influence the headline numbers the same as large ones.

Use this city view to compare ZIPs inside Middle Island against each other rather than hunting for a single "city average." The Affordability Dashboard linked below combines these Census inputs with HUD Fair Market Rents, FBI crime data, and Department of Labor childcare costs into a graded scorecard for Middle Island as a whole, while individual ZIP pages show fine-grained household income, housing profile, education attainment, commute time, and nearby-ZIP benchmarks. Every field on this page is sourced directly from U.S. Census Bureau ACS 2023 5-Year Estimates — no estimates, no proprietary scoring, no editorial adjustment.